1961 – Alex "Boo" Ellis, Wilkes-Barre Barons 1963 – Bobby McNeill, Camden Bullets 1964 – Jimmie Hadnot, Trenton Colonials 1965 – Bobby McNeill, Camden Bullets 1966 – Walt Simon, Allentown Jets 1967 – Willie Murrell, Scranton Miners 1968 – Willis "Spider" Bennett, Hartford Capitols 1969 – Jim Jackson, Scranton Miners 1970 – John Savage, Wilmington Blue Bombers 1971 – Willie Somerset, Scranton Apollos 1972 – Reggie Lacefield, Hartford Capitols 1977 – Jim Bostic, Jersey Shore Bullets 1978 – Jim Bostic, Jersey Shore Bullets 1979 – Andre McCarter, Rochester Zeniths 1982 – Brad Branson, Anchorage Northern Knights 1983 – Larry Spriggs, Albany Patroons 1984 – Anthony Roberts, Wyoming Wildcatters 1985 – Rick Lamb, Wyoming Wildcatters 1986 – Don Collins, Tampa Bay Thrillers
1987 – Eddie Johnson, Tampa Bay Thrillers 1988 – Michael Brooks, Albany Patroons 1989 – Dwayne McClain, Rockford Lightning 1990 – Conner Henry, Rapid City Thrillers 1991 – Vincent Askew, Albany Patroons 1992 – Conner Henry, Yakima Sun Kings 1993 – Pat Durham, Fargo-Moorhead Fever 1994 – Jeff Martin, Grand Rapids Hoops 1995 – Tony Dawson, Rockford Lightning 1996 – Shelton