John's PF 1986–87 Georgetown SF 1987–88 Pittsburgh PF 1988–89 Georgetown G 1989–90 Syracuse PF 1990–91 Syracuse SF/SG 1991–92 Georgetown C 1992–93 Seton Hall SG 1993–94 Connecticut F 1994–95 Villanova SG 1995–96 * Connecticut SG 1996–97 Notre Dame PF 1997–98 Connecticut SG/SF 1998–99^ (2) Connecticut SG/SF Miami SF 1999–00 Notre Dame PF 2000–01^ (2) Notre Dame PF Boston College G 2001–02^ Connecticut SF Pittsburgh PG 2002–03 (2) Boston College G 2003–04 * Connecticut C 2004–05 Syracuse PF 2005–06 Villanova G 2006–07 Georgetown F 2007–08 Notre Dame PF 2008–09^ Pittsburgh C Connecticut C 2009–10 Syracuse F 2010–11 Notre Dame SG 2011–12 Marquette PF 2012–13 Georgetown F 2013–14 * Creighton F 2014–15^ Villanova PG Providence PG 2015–16 (2) Providence PG 2016–17 Villanova SG 2017–18 * Villanova PG 2018–19 Marquette PG 2019–20 Seton Hall SG 2020–21^ Villanova PG Seton Hall PF Villanova PF