Pro Wrestling Guerrilla PWG World Championship (2 razy) PWG World Tag Team Championship (5 razy) – z Human Tornado (1), Quicksilverem (1), Kevinem Steenem (2) i Paulem Londonem (1) Battle of Los Angeles (2011) Dynamite Duumvirate Tag Team Title Tournament (2010) – z Paulem Londonem
Pro Wrestling Illustrated 23 miejsce na liście PWI 500 – 500 najlepszych wrestlerów 2015 roku.
Pro Wrestling Prestige PWP Heavyweight Championship (1 raz)
Puerto Rico Wrestling Association PRWA Caribbean Championship (1 raz)
Ring of Honor ROH World Tag Team Championship (1 raz)– z Kevinem Steenem ROH World Television Championship (1 raz)
SoCal Uncensored Match of the Year (2006) vs PAC z 18 listopada, Pro Wrestling Guerrilla Match of the Year (2007) vs Bryan Danielson z 29 lipca, Pro Wrestling Guerrilla Most Outstanding Wrestler (2006, 2007) Tag Team of the Year (2006) z Quicksilverem Wrestler of the Year (2007)
STHLM Wrestling STHLM Wrestling Championship (1 raz)
Westside Xtreme Wrestling wXw Unified World Wrestling Championship (1 raz) 16 Carat Gold Tournament (2012)
Wrestling Observer Newsletter Feud of the Year (2010) vs Kevin Steen